B ejected?


The editorial process is impersonal; do not take rejection personally. Keep trying.

  1. Will the next submission be affected by previous rejections?
    No. Your past history of success or failure has no bearing on your next submission. No causality, period. Editorial decisions are based on the contents or the ideas contained in that particular paper.

  2. Some papers are rejected because the ideas are not well developed in your paper. In this case, you may further refine the paper. If, as a result, the paper is different in substance, it can be submitted as a new paper.

  3. " 'The stupid referee' did not understand my paper."
    This is usually an expositional problem on your part.

  4. You may request a reconsideration of your paper if the negative decision was based on Both of these can be verified, in principle, by others. We will try to get another opinion.

  5. However, do not claim this too frequently, or you may lose credibility in the future.

  6. When you request a second or third opinion, specify the reasons: (i) incompetent referee, or (ii) mathematical/factual errors.

  7. If the rejection was based on other reasons (subjective opinions), do not attempt to question the decision. It is difficult to change the subjective opinions of referees.

  8. Your letter should specify the manuscript number. In addition, it should contain complete correspondence information about the author: (i)address, (ii) telephone and fax numbers, and (iii) email address. This enables the editorial office to contact you quickly should the need arise.

Submission | Before submission | Subscription | Referee report | Revising your paper | Rejected?| IREF Style | Editorial Board | Announcement | Principles | Who subscribes to IREF? | Volume 1 | Volume 2 | Volume 3 | Volume 4 | Volume 5 | RIE | IEFS | RDE | EDA | PER | HKEA

"Smell flowers once in a while." Callicarpa americana Texas A&M Botany Dept